Home

The_Team

Contact_Us

Feedback

FAQ

Glossary

NHS_Links

Help

   
   
Health Investment Plan - Public Consultation Feedback

    

PUBLIC CONSULTATION 
MENU 

Introduction
Introduction to the public consultation menu options

The Document
The public consultation document

Report to HA
The report submitted to the Health Authority on the outcome of Public Consultation

Service Capacity
The capacity of the local NHS to meet the demand for health services

Access Issues
Access to services, particularly hospitals

NHS Resources
The availability of resources, including funding

NHS Buildings
The quality and appropriateness of NHS buildings

FAQ
Frequently Asked Questions

CHC Survey Results
Full results on the first CHC survey

Questionnaire Results
Full results of the public consultation questionnaire

 

FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions)

spot.gif (1K)  Will any services that are currently provided in regional centres be provided locally?
spot.gif (1K)  What will happen to the Memorial Wing, will the World War I memorial be preserved?
spot.gif (1K)  What will happen to the vacated hospital site?
spot.gif (1K)  What will the new hospital be called?
spot.gif (1K)  Who decides on which site the new hospital will be located?
spot.gif (1K)  Why is ECH preferred when the PDH option costs less to run?
spot.gif (1K)  What does the private sector get out of providing the money to build the hospital?
spot.gif (1K)  Will you apply 'best value' practices to the PFI contract?
spot.gif (1K)  If the vacated hospital site is sold, who gets the money?
spot.gif (1K)  How much influence will Fenland PCT have in the outcome of the consultation?
spot.gif (1K)  Where are trained nursing staff going to live, will the hospital provide accommodation?
spot.gif (1K)  Will there be a stroke rehabilitation unit?
spot.gif (1K)  What is the Woman & Child Unit ?
spot.gif (1K)  Why so many single rooms?
spot.gif (1K)  Are potential staff dissuaded from working at PHT because it is not a teaching hospital?

Will any services that are currently provided in regional centres be provided locally?

We are working with the West Anglian Cancer Network to determine which cancer services currently provided at regional centres such as Addenbrookes Hospital, Cambridge, could be provided in Peterborough. Initial discussions have focused on the possibility of providing two Linear Accelerators in the new hospital. This would eliminate the need for patients with serious cancer problems the need to travel several time a week over 40 miles to Cambridge for their treatment. Similarly some cardiac treatments currently undertaken at Papworth could come to Peterborough

To The Top

What will happen to the Memorial Wing and will the World War I memorial be preserved?

The Memorial Wing is designated a 'building of local historic interest' and as such we must ensure it is preserved or sensitively incorporated into any developments on the site. We will work with the City Council to ensure the memorial has a safe future.

What will happen to the vacated hospital site?

Whichever site is vacated will probably be partly or wholly sold for redevelopment. The local planning authority, Peterborough City Council, will determine the future use of the site, based on local planning guidance.

What will the new hospital be called?

No decision has been taken on the name of the new hospital or how the name would be chosen.

To The Top

Who decides on which site the new hospital will be located?

The two local Primary Care Trusts and the Hospital Trust will make a joint recommendation to the Strategic Health Authority for Norfolk, Suffolk and Cambridgeshire based on their preferred choice. The Strategic Health Authority will consider the evidence supporting the choice and the results of the public consultation exercise. They will then decide whether to approve or reject the recommended choice.

Why is ECH preferred when the PDH option costs less to run?

The estimated costs in the strategic outline case approved in February 2001 were based on an initial set of assumptions and ideas about the probable design and cost of the redeveloped and expanded hospital buildings required to fit all our services on each site. We are currently developing these ideas in much more detail and have already identified several factors that mean the costs for the PDH option are understated. When the review is complete we expect the PDH option will be more costly than the ECH option.

However, cost is not the only factor we must consider when making a choice. The quality of the building, clinical safety and the flexibility of the design are all-important and may outweigh the cost of either option.

To The Top

What does the private sector get out of providing the money to build the hospital?

Under a publicly funded scheme the contractor would make a profit from constructing the building and service companies would make a profit by maintaining the building fabric, the heating boilers and other plant and services.

In a PFI project, the private sector does both of these and also provides the money required to fund the construction of the building and will expect to profit from this additional investment. However the overall cost to the Health Service, taking into account the risks that the private sector and the NHS will bear, must be less than the cost of funding the building from public funds. If it is not less, the project will not be approved.

To The Top

Will you apply 'best value' practices to the PFI contract?

The NHS does not have a direct equivalent to local authority initiative of 'best value'. However, there are several processes built into the PFI process that ensures the NHS gets good value for money and the private sector cannot make excessive profits.

The services provided by the private sector must be tested on a regular basis to ensure the NHS is not paying over the market rate. If the cost of a service is above the market rate it must be reduced.

In addition, if the private sector is able to renegotiate the terms under which it borrowed the money for the building, the NHS must benefit from any reduction in cost.

To The Top

If the vacated hospital site is sold, who gets the money?

As a three star trust, the hospital can keep 10% of any income from the sale of the land. The remainder goes back to the NHS. If the vacated site is incorporated into the private finance deal, the full value of the site could be used to partly offset the cost of the project.

How much influence will Fenland PCT have in the outcome of the consultation?

Only a small part of Fenland PCT's expenditure is included in the Health Investment Plan. The majority of Fenland patients go either to Hinchinbrooke Hospital in Huntingdon, the Queen Elizabeth Hospital in Kings Lynn, or Addenbrooke's Hospital in Cambridge. Fenland PCT is considering the development of a Health Care Centre in the March area. The majority of the cost of this facility would come from PCT funds that are outside the Health Investment Plan. Therefore any decision on the local Health Care Centre is entirely in the control of Fenland PCT.

To The Top

Where are trained nursing staff going to live? Will the hospital provide accommodation?

The NHS does provide limited accommodation for new recruits, but the local housing market and availability of private rented accommodation mean most staff prefer to make their own accommodation arrangements.

The NHS will continue to offer short-term accommodation for qualified staff, and will explore ways in which this can be expanded if it becomes essential for future staffing requirements.

Will there be a stroke rehabilitation unit?

Although the hospital currently has a Stroke Unit, the lack of space in the PDH tower block means we cannot provide a dedicated stroke rehabilitation unit. The new hospital will provide the opportunity to develop this important service and fully integrate it with the Stroke Unit.

To The Top

What is the Woman & Child Unit?  I have a problem with the gynaecology area, with endometriosis a lot of women cannot get pregnant. It is a bit insensitive if they are to be close to maternity patients.

Maternity, SCBU, children's' outpatients and wards, children's A&E will all be together in one unit. In the Women's Unit, obstetrics and gynaecology patients can be housed together and breast cancer patients can be cared and counselled in one area.

Infertility services and termination of pregnancy patients are also to be considered in this. The unit reflects where the clinical services are sited but segregation will occur to account for the sensitive issues around some of these services.

To The Top

Why so many single rooms? They are not always a good idea for patients, some patients do not like isolation and improve more quickly in a larger bedded area.

Views have been expressed both in favour of single rooms and by patients who prefer to be cared for with other patients. NHS guidelines require us to produce a plan providing up to 50% single rooms. This will give more flexibility over gender separation and help with the care of very ill patients.

Are potential staff dissuaded from working at Peterborough Hospital because it is not a teaching hospital?

Peterborough Hospitals Trust is slowly becoming a teaching hospital. We supply teaching services to Cambridge and Leicester and can now be described as an associated hospital of the Leicester Warwick Medical School. We do not have a problem in attracting good quality and highly qualified consultants because many do not wish to work in a teaching hospital.

To The Top